你认为是闻海虎论文造假，还是王牧污蔑闻海虎
作为一个曾经的南大物理人,我个人认为无论从哪个方面来讲我都是更偏向闻海虎的.
且不说学术之外的几乎是所有知情的人都一边倒地倒向闻海虎---可以在南大的BBS论坛上看一看;
单说学术以内的,我认真的看了相关论文以及双方的辩论,闻海虎那篇Nature communications论文中用的处理数据的手法,至多只能说是不够严谨,甚至你只能说你的观点和他不同.王牧的举报信里的内容只能反映出一个事实:要么是王故意歪曲了闻论文中的原意,要么就是王的学术水平不足,居然把论文的意思都看错了.
当然,最权威的是NATURE COMMUNICATIONS的编辑们的意见:该文章已经发表了,没有被要求撤稿.
所以结果是显而易见的.
闻海虎的个人论著
在包括NaturePhysics，NatureCommunications在内的SCI杂志上发表论文290余篇,他人引用超过5000次，h-index41,在国内外重要学术会议上作邀请报告90余场。 主要论文1. Xing, Jie; Li, Sheng; Zeng, Bin; Mu, Gang; Shen, Bing; Schneeloch, J.; Zhong, R. D.; Liu, T. S.; Gu, G. D.; Wen, Hai-Hu. Power-law-like correlation between condensation energy and supercon- ducting transition temperatures in iron pnictide/chalcogenide superconductors: Beyond the BCS understanding. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(14), 140503(2014). APR 16, 2014.2. Moll, Philip J. W.; Zhu, Xiyu; Cheng, Peng; Wen, Hai-Hu; Batlogg, Bertram. Intrinsic Josephson junctions in the iron-based multi-band superconductor (V2Sr4O6)Fe2As2. NATURE PHYSICS 10(9), 644-647(2014).3. Yi, M.; Zhang, Y.; Liu, Z. -K.; Ding, X.; Chu, J. -H.; Kemper, A. F.; Plonka, N.; Moritz, B.; Hashimoto, M.; Mo, S. -K.; Hussain, Z.; Devereaux, T. P.; Fisher, I. R.; Wen, H. H.; Shen, Z. -X.; Lu, D. H.Dynamic competition between spin-density wave order and superconductivity in underdoped Ba1-xKxFe2As2. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS 5, 3711(2014). APR 2014.4. Ding, Xiaxin; Pan, Yiming; Yang, Huan; Wen, Hai-Hu. Strong and nonmonotonic temperature dependence of Hall coefficient in superconducting KxFe2-ySe2 single crystals. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(22), 224515. JUN 25, 2014.5. Liu, Jianzhong; Li, Sheng; Li, Yufeng; Zhu, Xiyu; Wen, Hai-Hu. Pressure-tuned enhancement of superconductivity and change of ground state properties in LaO0.5F0.5BiSe2 single crystals. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 90(9), 094507(2014).6. Deng, Qiang; Ding, Xiaxin; Li, Sheng; Tao, Jian; Yang, Huan; Wen, Hai-Hu. The effect of impurity and the suppression of superconductivity in Na(Fe0.97-xCo0.03Tx)As (T = Cu, Mn). NEW JOURNAL OF PHYSICS 16, 063020(2014). JUN 12, 2014.7. Liu, Jianzhong; Fang, Delong; Wang, Zhenyu; Xing, Jie; Du, Zengyi; Li, Sheng; Zhu, Xiyu; Yang, Huan; Wen, Hai-Hu. Giant superconducting fluctuation and anomalous semiconducting normal state in NdO1-xFxBi1-yS2 single crystals. EPL 106(6), 67002 (2014). JUN 2014.8. Cho, K; Konczykowski, M; Murphy, J; Kim, H; Tanatar, MA; Straszheim, WE; Shen, B; Wen, HH. Effects of electron irradiation on resistivity and London penetration depth of Ba1-xKxFe2As2 (x <= 0.34) iron-pnictide superconductor. Prozorov, R. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 90(10), 104514 (2014).9. Che, RC; Han, F; Liang, CY; Zhao, XB; Wen, HH. Microstructural evolution and its influence on the superconductivity induced by oxygen vacancies in Sr2VO3-delta FeAs (delta=0.1, 0.5). PHYSICAL REVIEW B 90(10), 104503(2014).10. Abdel-Hafiez, M.; Pereira, P. J.; Kuzmichev, S. A.; Kuzmicheva, T. E.; Pudalov, V. M.; Harnagea, L.; Kordyuk, A. A.; Silhanek, A. V.; Moshchalkov, V. V.; Shen, B.; Wen, Hai-Hu; Vasiliev, A. N.; Chen, Xiao-Jia. Lower critical field and SNS-Andreev spectroscopy of 122-arsenides: Evidence of nodeless superconducting gap. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 90(5), 054524(2014). AUG 29 2014.11. Saint-Paul, M.; Guttin, C.; Abbassi, A.; Wang, Zhao-Sheng; Luo, Huiqian; Lu, Xingye; Ren, Cong; Wen, Hai-Hu; Hasselbach, K. Surface impedance in the antiferromagnetic and superconducting states of underdoped BaFe1.93Ni0.07As2 crystals. SOLID STATE COMMUNICATIONS 192, 47-50(2014). AUG 2014.12. Kim, H.; Tanatar, M. A.; Straszheim, W. E.; Cho, K.; Murphy, J.; Spyrison, N.; Reid, J. -Ph.; Shen, Bing; Wen, Hai-Hu; Fernandes, R. M.; Prozorov, R. Competition between superconductivity and magnetic/nematic order as a source of anisotropic superconducting gap in underdoped Ba1-xKxFe2As2. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 90(1) , 014517 (2014). JUL 28 2014.13. Ye, Z. R.; Yang, H. F.; Shen, D. W.; Jiang, J.; Niu, X. H.; Feng, D. L.; Du, Y. P.; Wan, X. G.; Liu, J. Z.; Zhu, X. Y.; Wen, H. H.; Jiang, M. H. Electronic structure of single-crystalline NdO0.5F0.5BiS2 studied by angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 90(4), 045116. JUL 17, 2014.14. Wang, Zhenyu; Fang, Delong; Deng, Qiang; Yang, Huan; Ren, Cong; Wen, Hai-Hu. Spectroscopic signature of Kondo screening on single adatoms in Na(Fe0.96Co0.03Mn0.01)As. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(21), 214515 (2014). JUN 27, 2014.15. Ning, F. L.; Fu, M.; Torchetti, D. A.; Imai, T.; Sefat, A. S.; Cheng, P.; Shen, B.; Wen, H. -H. Critical behavior of the spin density wave transition in underdoped Ba(Fe1-xCox)(2)As-2 (x <= 0.05): As-75 NMR investigation. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(21), 214511. JUN 25, 2014.16. Ueshima, Keiji; Han, Fei; Zhu, Xiyu; Wen, Hai-Hu; Kawasaki, Shinji; Zheng, Guo-qing. Magnetism and superconductivity in Sr2VFeAsO3 revealed by As-75- and V-51-NMR under elevated pressures. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(18), 184506 (2014). MAY 12, 2014.17. Saint-Paul, M.; Guttin, C.; Abbassi, A.; Wang, Zhao-Sheng; Luo, Huiqian; Lu, Xingye; Ren, Cong; Wen, Hai-Hu; Hasselbach, K. Surface impedance of BaFe2-xNixAs2 crystals. SOLID STATE COMMUNICATIONS 185, 10-13(2014). MAY 2014.18. Tanatar, M. A.; Straszheim, W. E.; Kim, Hyunsoo; Murphy, J.; Spyrison, N.; Blomberg, E. C.; Cho, K.; Reid, J. -Ph; Shen, Bing; Taillefer, Louis; Wen, Hai-Hu; Prozorov, R. Interplane resistivity of underdoped single crystals (Ba1-xKx)Fe2As2 (0 <= x < 0.34). PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(14), 144514(2014). APR 30, 2014.19. Ieki, E.; Nakayama, K.; Miyata, Y.; Sato, T.; Miao, H.; Xu, N.; Wang, X. -P.; Zhang, P.; Qian, T.; Richard, P.; Xu, Z. -J.; Wen, J. S.; Gu, G. D.; Luo, H. Q.; Wen, H. -H.; Ding, H.; Takahashi, T. Evolution from incoherent to coherent electronic states and its implications for superconductivity in FeTe1-xSex PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(14), 140506. APR 28, 2014.20. Li, Wei; Zhang, Chunfeng; Liu, Shenghua; Ding, Xiaxin; Wu, Xuewei; Wang, Xiaoyong; Wen, Hai-Hu; Xiao, Min. Mott behavior in KxFe2-ySe2 superconductors studied by pump-probe spectroscopy. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(13), 134515(2014). APR 22, 2014.21. Freitas, Daniele C.; Garbarino, Gaston; Weht, Ruben; Sow, Amadou; Zhu, Xiyu; Han, Fei; Cheng, Peng; Ju, Jing; Wen, Hai Hu. Manuel Hole doping by pressure on the 1111 pnictides CaFeAsF and SrFeAsF. Nunez-Regueiro. J. OF PHYS. CONDENSED MATTER 26(15), 155702(2014). APR 16, 2014.22. Tao Jian; Li Sheng; Zhu XiYu; Yang Huan. Growth and transport properties of CaFeAsF1-x single crystals. Wen HaiHu. SCIENCE CHINA-PHYSICS MECHANICS & ASTRONOMY 57(4), 632-636(2014). APR 2014.23. Evtushinsky, D. V.; Zabolotnyy, V. B.; Kim, T. K.; Kordyuk, A. A.; Yaresko, A. N.; Maletz, J.; Aswartham, S.; Wurmehl, S.; Boris, A. V.; Sun, D. L.; Lin, C. T.; Shen, B.; Wen, H. H.; Varykhalov, A.; Follath, R.; Buechner, B.; Borisenko, S. V. Strong electron pairing at the iron 3d(xz) (yz) orbitals in hole-doped BaFe2As2 superconductors revealed by angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(6), 064514(2014). FEB 27, 2014.24. Luo, Huiqian; Wen, Hai-Hu. Localization of charge carriers in the normal state of underdoped Bi2+xSr2-xCuO6+delta. PHYSICAL REVIEW B 89(2), 024506(2014). JAN 14, 2014.25. Li, Xueming; Ge, Binghui; Li, Fanghua; Luo, Huiqian; Wen, Haihu. A study of one-dimensional incommensurate modulated structure determination in high-resolution transmission electron microscopy. ACTA CRYSTALLOGRAPHICA A-FOUNDATION AND ADVANCES 70 (6), 563-571 (2014). NOV 2014.
